He is survived by his loving spouse Rosemarie; his daughter: Danielle Himick-Enriquez; his son James D. Himick; his stepdaughter Colleen Supanich De Azurdia; and his mother Catherine A. Himick; his sisters: Beth Bencievenga and Catherine Portela (Anthony). Jimmy also leaves behind his grandchildren: Andrew, Mason, Juliet, Josiah, and Antonio. Jimmy was predeceased by his father Raymond, and his sister Mary and her spouse Michael McMahon.

Jimmy is also survived my many nieces and nephews.